diff --git a/src/components/ProfileCard.tsx b/src/components/ProfileCard.tsx
index 47f31649c..3b719861f 100644
--- a/src/components/ProfileCard.tsx
+++ b/src/components/ProfileCard.tsx
@@ -38,7 +38,10 @@ import {
   ButtonText,
 } from '#/components/Button'
 import {EphemeralAccountSwitcher} from '#/components/EphemeralAccountSwitcher'
-import {Check_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as Check} from '#/components/icons/Check'
+import {
+  Check_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as Check,
+  DoubleCheck_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as DoubleCheck,
+} from '#/components/icons/Check'
 import {PlusLarge_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as Plus} from '#/components/icons/Plus'
 import {Link as InternalLink, type LinkProps} from '#/components/Link'
 import * as Pills from '#/components/Pills'
@@ -586,7 +589,10 @@ export function FollowButtonInner({
           void onPressUnfollow(e)
         }}>
         {withIcon && (
-          <ButtonIcon icon={Check} position={isRound ? undefined : 'left'} />
+          <ButtonIcon
+            icon={viewer.followedBy ? DoubleCheck : Check}
+            position={isRound ? undefined : 'left'}
+          />
         )}
         {isRound ? null : <ButtonText>{unfollowLabel}</ButtonText>}
       </Button>
diff --git a/src/components/ProfileHoverCard/index.web.tsx b/src/components/ProfileHoverCard/index.web.tsx
index af5d258b4..15cb1864b 100644
--- a/src/components/ProfileHoverCard/index.web.tsx
+++ b/src/components/ProfileHoverCard/index.web.tsx
@@ -30,7 +30,10 @@ import {atoms as a, useTheme} from '#/alf'
 import {Button, ButtonIcon, ButtonText} from '#/components/Button'
 import {useFollowMethods} from '#/components/hooks/useFollowMethods'
 import {useRichText} from '#/components/hooks/useRichText'
-import {Check_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as Check} from '#/components/icons/Check'
+import {
+  Check_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as Check,
+  DoubleCheck_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as DoubleCheck,
+} from '#/components/icons/Check'
 import {PlusLarge_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as Plus} from '#/components/icons/Plus'
 import {
   KnownFollowers,
@@ -513,7 +516,14 @@ function Inner({
               onPress={profileShadow.viewer?.following ? unfollow : follow}>
               <ButtonIcon
                 position="left"
-                icon={profileShadow.viewer?.following ? Check : Plus}
+                icon={
+                  profileShadow.viewer?.following &&
+                  profileShadow.viewer?.followedBy
+                    ? DoubleCheck
+                    : profileShadow.viewer?.following
+                      ? Check
+                      : Plus
+                }
               />
               <ButtonText>
                 {profileShadow.viewer?.following
diff --git a/src/components/icons/Check.tsx b/src/components/icons/Check.tsx
index fe9883baf..3c0c46ac3 100644
--- a/src/components/icons/Check.tsx
+++ b/src/components/icons/Check.tsx
@@ -7,3 +7,7 @@ export const Check_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded = createSinglePathSVG({
 export const CheckThick_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded = createSinglePathSVG({
   path: 'M21.474 2.98a2.5 2.5 0 0 1 .545 3.494l-10.222 14a2.5 2.5 0 0 1-3.528.52L2.49 16.617a2.5 2.5 0 0 1 3.018-3.986l3.75 2.84L17.98 3.525a2.5 2.5 0 0 1 3.493-.545Z',
 })
+
+export const DoubleCheck_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded = createSinglePathSVG({
+  path: 'M 18.850814,2.9270055 C 18.544206,2.9339155 18.258318,3.083265 18.077499,3.330976 L 9.3863645,15.392379 10.93107,16.617756 19.668374,4.4928718 C 19.988818,4.053997 19.893267,3.4385137 19.454847,3.1174487 19.279961,2.9891973 19.067634,2.9222535 18.850814,2.9270055 Z m 4.143583,0.055787 C 22.687789,2.9897025 22.4019,3.1390521 22.221082,3.386763 L 11.298491,18.318279 5.9026003,14.030422 C 4.8739764,13.212603 3.6485994,14.755385 4.6772234,15.573204 l 6.1980606,4.924592 c 0.438229,0.348133 1.078115,0.26159 1.408126,-0.190444 L 23.811956,4.5486583 C 24.1324,4.1097833 24.03685,3.4943001 23.598429,3.1732351 23.423543,3.0449836 23.211217,2.9780399 22.994397,2.9827925 Z M 0.97800837,14.174697 c -0.93232486,0.0069 -1.3340716,1.185102 -0.60018465,1.760156 L 6.5758845,20.859445 C 7.0141139,21.207578 7.6539998,21.121037 7.98401,20.669002 L 8.5341792,19.914924 C 6.2110596,18.089081 3.9159262,16.229985 1.6032007,14.392071 1.4261197,14.24966 1.2052421,14.172863 0.97800837,14.174697 Z',
+})
diff --git a/src/screens/PostThread/components/ThreadItemAnchorFollowButton.tsx b/src/screens/PostThread/components/ThreadItemAnchorFollowButton.tsx
index d639bcc44..70009f87e 100644
--- a/src/screens/PostThread/components/ThreadItemAnchorFollowButton.tsx
+++ b/src/screens/PostThread/components/ThreadItemAnchorFollowButton.tsx
@@ -17,7 +17,10 @@ import {atoms as a, useBreakpoints} from '#/alf'
 import {Button, ButtonIcon, ButtonText} from '#/components/Button'
 import {EphemeralAccountSwitcher} from '#/components/EphemeralAccountSwitcher'
 import {useEphemeralFollowAction} from '#/components/hooks/useEphemeralFollowAction'
-import {Check_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as CheckIcon} from '#/components/icons/Check'
+import {
+  Check_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as CheckIcon,
+  DoubleCheck_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as DoubleCheckIcon,
+} from '#/components/icons/Check'
 import {PlusLarge_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as PlusIcon} from '#/components/icons/Plus'
 import * as Toast from '#/components/Toast'
 import {IS_IOS} from '#/env'
@@ -161,7 +164,16 @@ function PostThreadFollowBtnLoaded({
       color={isFollowing ? 'secondary' : 'secondary_inverted'}
       style={enableSquareButtons ? [a.rounded_sm] : [a.rounded_full]}>
       {gtMobile && (
-        <ButtonIcon icon={isFollowing ? CheckIcon : PlusIcon} size="sm" />
+        <ButtonIcon
+          icon={
+            isFollowing && isFollowedBy
+              ? DoubleCheckIcon
+              : isFollowing
+                ? CheckIcon
+                : PlusIcon
+          }
+          size="sm"
+        />
       )}
       <ButtonText maxFontSizeMultiplier={2}>
         {!isFollowing ? (
@@ -179,21 +191,19 @@ function PostThreadFollowBtnLoaded({
     </Button>
   )
 
-  return (
-    currentAccount && hasAlternateAccounts ? (
-      <EphemeralAccountSwitcher
-        selectedDid={currentAccount.did}
-        title={_(msg`Follow as`)}
-        triggerBehavior="longPress"
-        onSelectAccount={account => {
-          void onSelectEphemeralAccount(account)
-        }}
-        renderTrigger={({triggerProps}) =>
-          renderFollowButton(triggerProps.onLongPress)
-        }
-      />
-    ) : (
-      renderFollowButton()
-    )
+  return currentAccount && hasAlternateAccounts ? (
+    <EphemeralAccountSwitcher
+      selectedDid={currentAccount.did}
+      title={_(msg`Follow as`)}
+      triggerBehavior="longPress"
+      onSelectAccount={account => {
+        void onSelectEphemeralAccount(account)
+      }}
+      renderTrigger={({triggerProps}) =>
+        renderFollowButton(triggerProps.onLongPress)
+      }
+    />
+  ) : (
+    renderFollowButton()
   )
 }
diff --git a/src/screens/Profile/Header/ProfileHeaderStandard.tsx b/src/screens/Profile/Header/ProfileHeaderStandard.tsx
index 084009882..0b6604954 100644
--- a/src/screens/Profile/Header/ProfileHeaderStandard.tsx
+++ b/src/screens/Profile/Header/ProfileHeaderStandard.tsx
@@ -42,9 +42,14 @@ import {SubscribeProfileButton} from '#/components/activity-notifications/Subscr
 import {Button, ButtonIcon, ButtonText} from '#/components/Button'
 import {DebugFieldDisplay} from '#/components/DebugFieldDisplay'
 import {useDialogControl} from '#/components/Dialog'
-import {EphemeralAccountSwitcher} from '#/components/EphemeralAccountSwitcher'
 import {MessageProfileButton} from '#/components/dms/MessageProfileButton'
+import {EphemeralAccountSwitcher} from '#/components/EphemeralAccountSwitcher'
+import {useEphemeralFollowAction} from '#/components/hooks/useEphemeralFollowAction'
 import {CalendarDays_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as CalendarDays} from '#/components/icons/CalendarDays'
+import {
+  Check_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as Check,
+  DoubleCheck_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as DoubleCheck,
+} from '#/components/icons/Check'
 import {Globe_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as Globe} from '#/components/icons/Globe'
 import {PlusLarge_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as Plus} from '#/components/icons/Plus'
 import {
@@ -65,7 +70,6 @@ import {ProfileHeaderHandle} from './Handle'
 import {ProfileHeaderMetrics} from './Metrics'
 import {ProfileHeaderShell} from './Shell'
 import {ProfileHeaderSuggestedFollows} from './SuggestedFollows'
-import {useEphemeralFollowAction} from '#/components/hooks/useEphemeralFollowAction'
 
 interface Props {
   profile: AppBskyActorDefs.ProfileViewDetailed
@@ -472,82 +476,91 @@ export function HeaderStandardButtons({
           )}
 
           {(!minimal || !profile.viewer?.following) &&
-            !(minimal && hideScaryFollowButtons) && (
-              (currentAccount && hasAlternateAccounts ? (
-                <EphemeralAccountSwitcher
-                  selectedDid={currentAccount.did}
-                  title={_(msg`Follow as`)}
-                  triggerBehavior="longPress"
-                  onSelectAccount={account => {
-                    void onSelectEphemeralAccount(account)
-                  }}
-                  renderTrigger={({triggerProps}) => (
-                    <Button
-                      testID={
-                        profile.viewer?.following ? 'unfollowBtn' : 'followBtn'
-                      }
-                      size="small"
-                      color={
-                        profile.viewer?.following ? 'secondary' : 'primary'
-                      }
-                      label={
-                        profile.viewer?.following
-                          ? _(msg`Unfollow ${profile.handle}`)
-                          : _(msg`Follow ${profile.handle}`)
-                      }
-                      onLongPress={triggerProps.onLongPress}
-                      onPress={
-                        profile.viewer?.following
-                          ? onPressUnfollow
-                          : onPressFollow
-                      }>
-                      {!profile.viewer?.following && <ButtonIcon icon={Plus} />}
-                      <ButtonText>
-                        {profile.viewer?.following ? (
-                          profile.viewer?.followedBy ? (
-                            <Trans>Mutuals</Trans>
-                          ) : (
-                            <Trans>Following</Trans>
-                          )
-                        ) : profile.viewer?.followedBy ? (
-                          <Trans>Follow back</Trans>
+            !(minimal && hideScaryFollowButtons) &&
+            (currentAccount && hasAlternateAccounts ? (
+              <EphemeralAccountSwitcher
+                selectedDid={currentAccount.did}
+                title={_(msg`Follow as`)}
+                triggerBehavior="longPress"
+                onSelectAccount={account => {
+                  void onSelectEphemeralAccount(account)
+                }}
+                renderTrigger={({triggerProps}) => (
+                  <Button
+                    testID={
+                      profile.viewer?.following ? 'unfollowBtn' : 'followBtn'
+                    }
+                    size="small"
+                    color={profile.viewer?.following ? 'secondary' : 'primary'}
+                    label={
+                      profile.viewer?.following
+                        ? _(msg`Unfollow ${profile.handle}`)
+                        : _(msg`Follow ${profile.handle}`)
+                    }
+                    onLongPress={triggerProps.onLongPress}
+                    onPress={
+                      profile.viewer?.following
+                        ? onPressUnfollow
+                        : onPressFollow
+                    }>
+                    {profile.viewer?.following && profile.viewer?.followedBy ? (
+                      <ButtonIcon icon={DoubleCheck} />
+                    ) : !profile.viewer?.following ? (
+                      <ButtonIcon icon={Plus} />
+                    ) : (
+                      <ButtonIcon icon={Check} />
+                    )}
+                    <ButtonText>
+                      {profile.viewer?.following ? (
+                        profile.viewer?.followedBy ? (
+                          <Trans>Mutuals</Trans>
                         ) : (
-                          <Trans>Follow</Trans>
-                        )}
-                      </ButtonText>
-                    </Button>
-                  )}
-                />
-              ) : (
-                <Button
-                  testID={profile.viewer?.following ? 'unfollowBtn' : 'followBtn'}
-                  size="small"
-                  color={profile.viewer?.following ? 'secondary' : 'primary'}
-                  label={
-                    profile.viewer?.following
-                      ? _(msg`Unfollow ${profile.handle}`)
-                      : _(msg`Follow ${profile.handle}`)
-                  }
-                  onPress={
-                    profile.viewer?.following ? onPressUnfollow : onPressFollow
-                  }>
-                  {!profile.viewer?.following && <ButtonIcon icon={Plus} />}
-                  <ButtonText>
-                    {profile.viewer?.following ? (
-                      profile.viewer?.followedBy ? (
-                        <Trans>Mutuals</Trans>
+                          <Trans>Following</Trans>
+                        )
+                      ) : profile.viewer?.followedBy ? (
+                        <Trans>Follow back</Trans>
                       ) : (
-                        <Trans>Following</Trans>
-                      )
-                    ) : profile.viewer?.followedBy ? (
-                      <Trans>Follow back</Trans>
+                        <Trans>Follow</Trans>
+                      )}
+                    </ButtonText>
+                  </Button>
+                )}
+              />
+            ) : (
+              <Button
+                testID={profile.viewer?.following ? 'unfollowBtn' : 'followBtn'}
+                size="small"
+                color={profile.viewer?.following ? 'secondary' : 'primary'}
+                label={
+                  profile.viewer?.following
+                    ? _(msg`Unfollow ${profile.handle}`)
+                    : _(msg`Follow ${profile.handle}`)
+                }
+                onPress={
+                  profile.viewer?.following ? onPressUnfollow : onPressFollow
+                }>
+                {profile.viewer?.following && profile.viewer?.followedBy ? (
+                  <ButtonIcon icon={DoubleCheck} />
+                ) : !profile.viewer?.following ? (
+                  <ButtonIcon icon={Plus} />
+                ) : (
+                  <ButtonIcon icon={Check} />
+                )}
+                <ButtonText>
+                  {profile.viewer?.following ? (
+                    profile.viewer?.followedBy ? (
+                      <Trans>Mutuals</Trans>
                     ) : (
-                      <Trans>Follow</Trans>
-                    )}
-                  </ButtonText>
-                </Button>
-              ))
-            )}
+                      <Trans>Following</Trans>
+                    )
+                  ) : profile.viewer?.followedBy ? (
+                    <Trans>Follow back</Trans>
+                  ) : (
+                    <Trans>Follow</Trans>
+                  )}
+                </ButtonText>
+              </Button>
+            ))}
         </>
       ) : null}
       <ProfileMenu profile={profile} />
diff --git a/src/view/com/notifications/NotificationFeedItem.tsx b/src/view/com/notifications/NotificationFeedItem.tsx
index b9613ec8e..327e05a34 100644
--- a/src/view/com/notifications/NotificationFeedItem.tsx
+++ b/src/view/com/notifications/NotificationFeedItem.tsx
@@ -47,7 +47,10 @@ import {PreviewableUserAvatar, UserAvatar} from '#/view/com/util/UserAvatar'
 import {atoms as a, platform, useTheme} from '#/alf'
 import {Button, ButtonIcon, ButtonText} from '#/components/Button'
 import {BellRinging_Filled_Corner0_Rounded as BellRingingIcon} from '#/components/icons/BellRinging'
-import {Check_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as CheckIcon} from '#/components/icons/Check'
+import {
+  Check_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as CheckIcon,
+  DoubleCheck_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as DoubleCheckIcon,
+} from '#/components/icons/Check'
 import {
   ChevronBottom_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as ChevronDownIcon,
   ChevronTop_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as ChevronUpIcon,
@@ -835,7 +838,7 @@ function FollowBackButton({profile}: {profile: AppBskyActorDefs.ProfileView}) {
           size="small"
           style={[a.self_start]}
           onPress={onPressUnfollow}>
-          <ButtonIcon icon={CheckIcon} />
+          <ButtonIcon icon={isFollowedBy ? DoubleCheckIcon : CheckIcon} />
           <ButtonText>
             {isFollowedBy ? <Trans>Mutuals</Trans> : <Trans>Following</Trans>}
           </ButtonText>